Cameron McAllister, Reel
Georgia:
"Structurally similar and overflowing with character,
the film would fit right in alongside the works of Elia
Kazan from the 1950's and 60's. The visual elegance
achieved through harnessing the sunkissed Americana is
reminiscent of 'The Tree of Life,' despite Malick's
broader scale and sprawling esotericism. Director of
photography Adam Stone, having worked with Nichols on
all previous films, gives us his best work yet -
capturing the tree crowns, sand dunes and swift currents
of the river with a colorful sophistication. The oxbows
and islands of the Mighty Mississippi comprise as exotic
a location as any American film could hope for, rivaling
'Beasts of the Southern Wild' in visual novelty... It's
nice to see Sam Shepard aging into these kinds of
roles - perfectly tailored but showcasing a finespun
range."
Matthew Odam, Austin
Statesman:
"Can you imagine a better actor to portray a
charming ex-con with stars in his eyes and poetry in his
heart than Matthew McConaughey? Or a better actor to
play a fresh-faced teen confronted with the difficulties
of marriage and the pain of first rejection than Tye
Sheridan? And who could play a grizzled ol’ cuss and
father figure better than Sam Shepard?"
Joel D. Amos, Movie
Fanatic:
"Writer-director Jeff Nichols astounds us again after
his stellar work on his last film, the Michael Shannon
starring 'Take Shelter'... Shepard, as usual,
gives us his steely grace -- why isn’t this guy working
more?!"
A.A. Dowd, Time Out Chicago:
"The movie works best when just quietly tracing the
rhythms of its richly sketched milieu... fine turns by
Sam Shepard as an aged sharpshooter, Nichols regular
Michael Shannon doing his usual oddball thing, and the
good-in-everything-these-days McConaughey."
Erlingur Gretar, Filmophilia:
"The story is a simple one, some would say cliched,
others classic, but it is filled with fleshed out,
intriguing and empathetic characters... Sam Shepard
pops up and delights as Tom Blankenship, a man with a
complicated connection to Mud."
Tom Basham, Potomac Local News:
"Sam Shepard shines as Tom Blankenship, the guy
who raised Mud and sees him as a train wreck. He does
not know whether to help or run in the other direction."
Dan O'Neill, Delco News:
"Nichols assembled a fine cast which includes Reese
Witherspoon and Michael Shannon. But the one who really
steals the spotlight away from them all is Sam
Shepard."
David Denby, New Yorker:
"The movie is formally plotted, with many symmetries and
variations; children without parents is the dominant
structural device. But it also has its rough and
scraggly look, and actors with the worn faces of
hard-working country people - especially Sam Shepard
as a mysterious old man living on the other side of the
river from Ellis, and Sarah Paulson as Ellis’s mother.
Nichols has developed a talent for intimacy and for
continuous tension—he could be developing into one of
the great movie storytellers."
Philip Martin, Arkansas
Democrat-Gazette:
"It is a boys’ adventure story graced with magical
realism and touched up with some gritty Southern
naturalism. It is indisputably one of the best films of
its rare type, a thoughtful and accessible movie that
might be enjoyed (and even cherished) by all ages...
Sam Shepard shows up as yet another complicated
father figure, and he gives the part his full
attention."
Jason Solomons, The Guardian:
"The boys are beautifully played by Tye Sheridan and
Jacob Lofland. The teenagers' thrill and adventure in
secretly aiding Mud gives the film a Huckleberry
Finn-ish flavour that blends with something akin to Rob
Reiner's 1986 classic Stand By Me and Charles
Laughton's The Night of the Hunter...
Writer-director Nichols, working with cinematographer
Adam Stone, succeeds in capturing the life and the
geography of his locale, its beauty and its dangers...Mud
is a very fine film about innocence, father figures and
love, a work that manages to be thrilling, unsentimental
and emotionally rewarding."
Ned Lannamann, Portland Mercury:
"The best parts of Mud all involve the two kids, but
there are some terrific supporting performances, too: a
steely Sam Shepard as the creepy old man who
lives across the river, and a hilarious Michael Shannon
as Neckbone's philandering uncle."
Ann Hornaday, Daily Herald:
"The film is drenched in the humidity and salty air of a
Delta summer, often recalling the musical, aphoristic
cadences of Sam Shepard, who happens to appear in
a supporting role."
Robbie Collin, The Telegraph:
"There is much to admire here. McConaughey invests
the title role with a gravelly drawl and quaggy charisma
and both of the youngsters are excellent. Nichols also
seasons his script with a generous shaking of good ol’,
down-home, Southern-fried symbolism... Adam Stone,
Nichols’ regular cinematographer, shoots the delta in
anamorphic 35mm, and draws out the timeless beauty of
the landscape with its hazy light and soil the colour of
rust and oxidised copper."
Roger Moore, Movie Nation:
"The cinema’s leading purveyor of Southern Gothic,
Jeff Nichols, hands Matthew McConaughey his latest tour
de force turn in 'Mud', a down and dirty melodrama...
Nichols has cooked up an exotic stew that includes
obsessive love, a woman unworthy of it, a criminal on
the run and coming of age tale set against a dying way
of life in backwaters Arkansas. Great performances by
McConaughey, a Britney-trashy Reese Witherspoon, a
couple of kids, Sam Shepard and Ray McKinnon mark
this as one not to miss."
James Mottram, The List:
"Benefitting from McConaughey on a hot streak,
Nichols also draws fine naturalistic turns from his two
spirited teenagers. There are small but vital
contributions from Sam Shepard and Nichols
regular Michael Shannon, while Witherspoon brings
understated poignancy to her role. By Nichols’ already
high standards, this feels a minor work – but it’s been
made with love."
Mick LaSalle, San Francisco
Chronicle:
"Nichols gets winning performances from everybody,
including Sam Shepard, as a mysterious old man
with secrets and hidden talents, and Michael Shannon,
who is odd and funny in his brief appearances."
Film critic Susan Granger:
"After starring in four films last year, Matthew
McConaughey continues to ooze irresistible charm,
explaining how he had to murder his girlfriend’s abusive
ex-boyfriend. Sam Shepard appears briefly but
convincingly, offering support for Mud, yet it’s a shame
that Reese Witherspoon’s fickle, trampy part is so
underwritten."
NYUNews:
"Sam Shepard also gives a standout performance as
Ellis’ neighbor, Tom Blankenship, who has a mysterious
past with Mud. Shepard plays the part with just the
right amount of stoicism and pain."
Peter Debruge, Variety:
"One part The Night of the Hunter, two parts
Huckleberry Finn, Mud may be born of the
same rustic sensibility that fueled everyone from Andrew
Wyeth to Terrence Malick, but Nichols expresses this
outlook in a decidedly personal way."
Kristopher Tapley, HitFix:
"Nichols, truly gifted with actors, gets stellar
performances across the board. Reese Witherspoon, Sam
Shepard, Ray McKinnon and Sarah Paulson all shine,
and even fleeting work from Michael Shannon and the
great Joe Don Baker leaves you wanting more... This one
found a place inside me and it's staying there. I can
just tell. And I hope when it comes around your way, you
feel similarly."
Matt
Goldberg, Collider:
"Jeff Nichols‘ 'Mud' almost has it all. It’s a sweet
coming-of-age story, an adventure, a crime-thriller, and
a romance. Lead actors Tye Sheridan and Matthew
McConaughey give outstanding performances as a boy and a
man, respectively, who bristle when the world won’t
conform to the mythic journey they’ve envisioned.
Nichols gives the movie a sweet, soft, and loving tone
that takes the best of identity of the Deep South (i.e.
avoids racism), and uses it as a rich backdrop for a
captivating tale."
Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat, Spirituality & Practice:
"McConaughey is credible as Mud, the romantic dreamer,
and Sam Shepard puts in a notable performance as
a tough old man who provides needed support for the
fugitive when he needs it most."
Chris
Bumbray, JoBlo:
"As usual for a Nichols movie, MUD is stunningly
photographed, having been shot by Adam Stone, in a way
that's more stylized than TAKE SHELTER. The casting is
also pitch-perfect, with Witherspoon having a meatier
part than she's had in years, even though she probably
only has about fifteen minutes of screen-time. Nichols'
usual leading man, Michael Shannon has a welcome,
extended cameo as Neckbone's neer'do well, but kindly
uncle- who works as a pearl diver when not seducing the
local gals by playing “Help Me Rhonda” by The Beach
Boys, or playing hilariously bad on his electric guitar.
Meanwhile, Sam Shepard comes along and steals
every scene he's in as Mud's pseudo father figure- who
Mud claims is an ex-C.I.A assassin- and just may in fact
be that."
Film critic Anthony Marcusa:
"Mud is a marked departure for McConaughey,
and though he does take off his shirt, the character is
tender, yet powerful, and you can’t but help to root for
him. Director Jeff Nichols brings out the best in his
characters, expertly balancing innocence and guilt,
charming the audiences here and there. Winning
performances, a compelling yet simple story that is
dramatic but not overdramatic, and endearing characters
make for a stellar combination."
Todd McCarthy, The Hollywood Reporter:
"Sam Shepard puts far more than his recent norm
into his acute characterization of a man who may or may
not be Mud’s real father and may or may not have been a
government hit man."
Hillary Weston, Black Book:
"In their Cannes review, The Film Stage claimed that
'imperfect as it may be, it marks a step forward for
Nichols as a filmmaker capable of making big
entertainment that retains some intelligence and a
palpable message as well.' And if you aren't sold
already, Sam Shepard is also in the film and,
let's face it, that's reason enough."
Robert Bell, Exclaim, ca:
"Shot with a classical eye that frames each shot
beautifully, but without any distracting or imposing
viewpoint, there is a timeless nature to 'Mud' that
matches the overriding, universal themes perfectly. As
characters repeat cycles of damaging behaviour, or
acknowledge their need to escape the unbalanced and
emotionally abusive relationships they've trapped
themselves in, similarly believing in the myth of
romantic love, there is a pained observation that not
all things in life are worth fighting for... there is a
powerful unifying worldly understanding and tone here
that demonstrates Nichols' implicit talent and strong
voice."
|