Jason McKiernan, Filmcritic.com:
"Baby
Boom"
is light, easy fun with some strong feminism snuck
through the back door... What makes this
particular parental comedy so unique is that, unlike
similar films of the time period, this one is actually
about a woman, one who has succeeded well outside the
typical maternal realm, who is thrust into motherhood
and proves that a woman need not solely be defined by
any one societal label.... Keaton is fabulous in roles
like this, where she plays the nervous,
infectiously-spastic independent woman who has needs,
particularly when they are written with equal parts
gushy sweetness and savage wit by Nancy Meyers....
Eventually J.C. (Keaton) leaves her hectic NYC life for
a slower, calmer existence in snowy small-town Vermont,
where she discovers that a working mom can indeed have
it all - including the perfect New England man, played
here by Sam Shepard at his most down-home and
handsome.... It is audience-friendly,
warm-hearted, fuzzy happiness with a soft-focus bow on
top. There are lots of cute jokes, many convenient plot
developments, and endless simplistic characterizations.
But the material reaches high for a female protagonist
even by today's standards, let alone 1987's. Meyers was
on the cutting edge of the
independent-women-who-need-love-but-also-can-succeed-on-their-own
movement in modern cinema, and Baby Boom was
there at the beginning of an era.
Time-out Film Guide:
It's
played like a '40s comedy; heartwarming, sentimental,
simplistic.
Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun Times:
"Baby Boom" makes no effort to show us real life.
It is a fantasy about mothers and babies and sweetness
and love, with just enough wicked comedy to give it an
edge. The screenplay, written by producer Nancy Meyers
and director Charles Shyer, has some of the same
literate charm as their previous film, Irreconcilable
Differences, and some of the same sly observation of
a generation that wages an interior war between
selfishness and good nature.
JoAnn Rhetts, The Charlotte Observer:
Diane Keaton is so funny and appealing! In fact, "Baby
Boom" is Keaton`s best work since "Annie Hall"... She`s
brassy, glamorous, sexy and fiercely tender. She
finishes most of her sentences, and sometimes she`s as
gifted a physical comic as Steve Martin. Lugging vast
quantities of baby accessories, her glasses slide down
her nose, her bangs flop into her eyes and her Tiger
Lady collapses into Raggedy Ann. One kiss, in particular, is a slapstick marvel.
Philip Wuntch, The Dallas Morning News:
The film contains memorable bits of funny business.
Keaton's moments of comic hysteria are extremely
well-played, and some of the jabs taken at Yuppie
parenting are funny without being overly righteous. The
episode wherein Keaton first meets a Vermont
veterinarian played by Sam Shepard is engaging, and
their hesitant romance is charmingly presented.
Ben Falk, BBC:
J.C. buys a decrepit pad in snowy Vermont
and quits the rat race to care for her new infant. Soon,
she has her eye on local vet Dr Jeff, a very smooth
Shepard...
As a gentle comedy, this works in spades and while
lesser actors may well have relegated it to made-for-telly
cheese, Keaton is, of course, loaded with charisma and
comic sense. Okay, so the message may be a little
old-fashioned, but forget that and enjoy this for the
light-hearted fun.
Janet
Maslin, NY Times:
Miss Keaton's comically exaggerated toughness
and absurd self-confidence make the performance a
delight. For an hour or so, at least, ''Baby Boom'' is
wicked enough to have a real edge... The film also
does well when it pokes fun at the high-pressure world
of the New York child, a world in which bewildered tots
attend strenuous gym classes while their parents wail
over private-school rejections.
Joe Baltake, Sacramento Bee:
Let's not mince any words: Diane Keaton's triumphant new
movie, ""Baby Boom,'' is the funniest and most moving,
and least sentimental, chronicle of these confused
times, a movie at once retro and savvy. It plays as if
one of those irresistible Doris Day comedies of the '60s
had been plucked out of its fluff and plunged into some
politically sensitive territory... Shepard is the quiet
center of the movie. He becomes a friend fast. And I
particularly liked the work of James Spader as Keaton's
skunky protege. They all make good company.
Glenn Lovell, Mercury
News:
The new Diane Keaton vehicle "Baby Boom" proves an
immensely satisfying, often genuinely moving story about
sacrifice and altering priorities in the '80s... This is
Keaton's richest, most well-rounded performance since
"Annie Hall." Only here she's not only manic and funny,
she also establishes herself as a feisty romantic lead
of the Jean Arthur-Carole Lombard school...
Actor-playwright Shepard as a small-town rube patterned
after Jimmy Stewart, is certainly one of the screen's
more likable and unaffected actors.
Scott
Renshaw, Apollo Guide:
When she’s in top form, Keaton can play endearingly
frantic like no other actress can (like a tirade at her
Vermont plumber that "I don’t want to know where [my
water] comes from"). There’s enough charm and
intelligence in Keaton’s portrayal of J.C.’s uncertainty
that Baby Boom seems to glide over its easy jokes
and awkward structure.
Movieeye.com:
Diane Keaton gives one of her best performances
in "Baby Boom," a feminine-powered comedy
with a great deal of good-natured laughs up its business
suit sleeve... Written by Nancy Meyers and Charles Shyer
and directed by Shyer, "Baby Boom" provides a number of
comedic situations where inexperience and awkwardness
reign supreme. Watching Keaton's character feed her new
arrival linguini one minute and clean it off of the
ceiling the next is pure gold, as are her outbursts once
she reaching the breaking point after a harsh winter
takes its toll on her ancient Vermont home. When she
meets local veterinarian Sam Shepard, the changes are
evident in her personality and her outlook on life, and
Keaton brings out these the subtleties with grace and
ease. She has the ability to go from hot-shot career
woman to sensible country mom in a convincing manner,
and it helps that the material affords her room to do so
by not suffocating her in a barrage of tepid situations
or unwanted plot turns.
Jim Emerson, The Orange County Register:
Watching Keaton in this part is like discovering an
entirely new, mature comic actress spring from inside
the one we've been familiar with all these years. She
is, as they say, a revelation. Some of the trademark
Keaton mannerisms are still there - the waving fingers,
the stammer - but this is definitely not just a
hardened, capitalistic version of Annie Hall. This is
Keaton's most accomplished screen work, a virtuoso
performance in which she masterfully orchestrates every
behavioral detail - posture, facial expressions, vocal
inflections - without coming across as fussy or
mannered.
Ben Yagoda, Philadelphia Daily News:
You have to admit that "Baby Boom" does a nice job. Like
"Private Benjamin" and "Irreconcilable Differences,"
it's a product of the husband-and-wife team of Charles
Shyer and Nancy Meyers. (He directs, she produces, they
write). In this film, they've put together an odd but
effective combination of styles: '30s screwball comedies
(in which people like Rosalind Russell wore suits and in
which sojourns to the country were often taken), '50s
corporate comedies like "The Apartment" and very
up-to-date references.
Jack Sommersby, Efilmcritic.com:
"Baby Boom"
doesn't have so much as a single laugh-out-loud moment
and yet is uncommonly measured and deliberate in its putting
a constant smile on your face throughout. Instead of
"moments", it offers up a series of smoothly connected
instances that play off each other beautifully. You feel
as if what you're watching could conceivably happen
given the circumstances, and the absence of
sensationalistic excess in the plotting and execution
comes off not only as intelligent, but absolutely
essential for the sake of the story... Throw in a
late-in-the-game love interest in the person of local
veterinarian Dr. Jeff Cooper (an appealing Sam Shepard),
and you have a film that pretty much covers all the
bases without coming off as too perfunctory.
Michael Healy, Los
Angeles Daily News:
"Baby Boom" is an entertaining, high-gloss situation
comedy that should please the crowd that liked "The Big
Chill"... Diane Keaton does her best, most emotionally
complex work here since ''Shoot the Moon" (1982).
Paul, Willistein, The Morning Call:
"Baby Boom" is surprisingly tough-minded. The
script by Nancy Meyers and Charles Shyer is post Women's
Liberation but not a '50s "Father Knows Best" throwback.
Politics aside, "Baby Boom" offers a few belly laughs, a
fair share of chuckles and lots of warmth. Keaton
has finally found a non-Woody Allen movie to equal a
Woody Allen movie.
|